Category Archives: Suspension

Hey Lawrie, let’s refocus that intensity. You also deserve a suspension.

Jays third baseman Brett Lawrie is looking at some form of suspension after a temper tantrum over two poorly called strikes against him in the bottom of the ninth resulting in his ejection.
photo from Toronto Star

LIVINGSTONE: The Jays have looked like a team who left its defense at home the last three games. Seven errors in three losses resulting in nine unearned runs – six coming in the 7-1 loss to the Rays Monday night and three again Tuesday night, on four errors, against the divisional rivals.

The frustration seemed to boil over Tuesday night for a team determined to compete, but coming up short defensively. Bright side? The Jays have turned 50 double plays in 37 games according to, six more than the Baltimore Orioles. Sadly, however, they’ve committed 41 errors in 38 games (37 in 37, but tack on the four from Tuesday night and there you have it). That’s anything short of good. They lead the league in errors and the fielding – both infield and outfield – has been a big part of the Jays struggles. Let’s not forget the seven blown saves so far this season – but defense wins championships, or at least plays a huge part of it, and the Jays certainly aren’t playing in the field like contenders.

But that’s neither here nor there. What really needs to be said in this post is with respect to Brett Lawrie. Jays fans young and old alike love this kid for his high energy approach and league-leading level of intensity. He plays every game like it’s a game seven in the World Series. Fans love it – even fans from other teams can appreciate his youthful energy. He brings something to the game that isn’t seen in many organizations and it’s a breath of fresh air (cliched?) for a club – and a fan base – dying to be relevant again.

But he went too far Tuesday night when he threw one of the biggest temper tantrum’s seen in recent memory. Down a run in the bottom of the ninth, Lawrie came up to bat with one out. With a 3-1 count, closer Fernando Rodney threw what looked like – and even someone sitting in the 500-level at the Skydome could see it was – ball four and made his move for first. Home plate umpire Bill Miller wasn’t having it and called it a strike. Visibly frustrated by the call, Lawrie stepped back in and took what looked to be ball five high and outside.

Lawrie made two steps toward first before Miller called strike three throwing Lawrie into a fit of rage. He went straight at Miller and in the process, slammed his helmet at the feet of the umpire, bouncing it off the side of his leg. Miller looked stunned by the move and Lawrie continued to scream every obscenity in the book at the veteran umpire. It took coach Brian Butterfield to keep Lawrie from getting back into Miller’s face. Mere minutes after and about fifty f-bombs later, Manager John Farrell was ejected.

Don’t get me wrong: Lawrie had every right to be upset about the two terrible calls made by Miller. They dictated how the end of the game would go, and in a 4-3 game, it was far from over. It seems Miller took Lawrie’s initial move to first personal, like he was showing up the seasoned ump.

Sportsnet baseball guru Mike Wilner said something to this effect in the post-game show on FAN590 and I would agree. Miller made it about him.

Even if that fifth ball, high and outside, had ended up in the dirt three feet in front of the plate, Miller would’ve called it a strike. Lawrie’s reaction, however, was completely uncalled for. The frustration didn’t have to be such a spectacle. Argue the strikes, get tossed, curse at the umpire, but the reaction was that of a guy who needs to figure out how to get his emotions in check. At 21, Lawrie has a long way to go before he matures and it certainly showed Tuesday night.

Last year, Yadier Molina, catcher for the St. Louis Cardinals, got five games for bumping an umpire over a bad call. If Lawrie gets less than 10 games, I’d be surprised. It could end up being more, as Wilner pointed out, if the league disciplinarian determines Lawrie was intentional in hitting Miller with his helmet.

Lawrie deserves to be suspended and I hope that kind of embarrassing display doesn’t happen again. That’s not what the Jays are about. Sure, the passion and intensity is there, but it needs to be channeled into making quality plays on the field, picking good pitches to hit and then hitting the cover off the ball.

The opportunity for the Jays to be contenders is in their grasp. Discipline and focus is going to get them into the playoffs. They need to find it quick.

Tagged , , , , , ,

Dear Cole Hamels: Shut up, grow up and play the game

Phillies pitcher Cole Hamels, left, admitted after a game on Sunday that he intentionally hit Nats’ rookie Bryce Harper. Seriously? Grow up and play the game you get millions of dollars to play. That five game suspension you got is fitting for your idiocy.

McGILLIGAN: Cole Hamels is a 28-year-old major league pitcher.

Bryce Harper is a 19-year-old up-and-coming player.

That’s where this story should have ended. Unfortunately it didn’t. We ended up watching the 28-year-old act much less mature than the 19-year-old and chalking it up to some ridiculous baseball code.

Hamels admitted to intentionally beaning Harper in the first inning of the Philadelphia Phillies 9-3 win Sunday against the Washington Nationals.

Here’s what Hamels said about the incident to the Associated Press:

“That’s something I grew up watching, that’s kind of what happened, so I’m just trying to continue the old baseball because I think some people are kind of getting away from it. I remember when I was a rookie the strike zone was really, really small and you didn’t say anything because that’s the way baseball is. But I think unfortunately the league’s protecting certain players and making it not that old-school, prestigious way of baseball.”

Hamels is wrong, in my opinion, for a number of reasons.

You want to make a point to a rookie? Strike him out. Don’t throw at him and pretend you’re protecting the reputation of the game – you’re not. The fact that Harper stole home that same inning is priceless. Do pitchers like it when a kid comes to the big leagues, has immediate success and is excited about it? No, but it doesn’t mean you intentionally throw at some one.

Grow up.

And don’t hide behind some ancient code. If that pitch slipped a bit out of Hamels hand and hit Harper in the head causing a concussion, we’re having a very different conversation and I bet Hamels doesn’t admit to it.

As for the conspiracy theory of the league protecting certain players, that doesn’t even make sense. How is the league protecting Harper? He’s a 19-year-old kid facing major league pitching; the fact that he’s handling it like a veteran is a testament to his skills and quick development.

Did the league tell other pitchers to groove fastballs to Harper or instruct umpires to adjust their strike zones for him? I’m sure MLB did not.

So if Hamels wants to be old school and protect the prestigious way of baseball, here’s my suggestion: Shut up and play.

LIVINGSTONE note: As I posted this piece, Hamels was handed down a five game suspension for intentionally throwing at Harper. In my own words: Good. What an idiot.